Best eroge of 2009 by 2ch
Each person could vote for up to 6 different titles, and each person could give an additional +1 or +2 points to a title he feels was really game (total of 3 extra points to spend). With each game vote the person can choose one aspect of the game which he thought was exceptionally good, so games with good scenario get a higher score in the scenario section and games with better “gaming” get a higher score in the Playability section.
S: Scenario
C: Character, Voice
G: Graphics, effects
M: Music
P: Playability
H: The ero in the game on a scale of 1 to 5, averaged out
1st place
BALDR SKY Dive2 “RECORDARE”
Released 27/11/2009 by Giga
S:40 C:9 G:3 M:16 P:124 H:2.33
413 pts
2nd place
BALDR SKY Dive1 “LostMemory”
Released 27/03/2009 by Giga
S:29 C:6 G:2 M:10 P:130 H:2.65
360pts
3rd place
装甲悪鬼村正 -FullMetalDaemon MURAMASA-
Released 30/10/2009 by Nitro+
S:115 C:9 G:18 M:2 P:0 H:1.87
337pts
4th place
Ore tachi ni tsubasa wa nai
Released 24/04/2009 by Navel
S:89 C:64 G:0 M:0 P:0 H:1.94
329pts
5th place
Hoshizora no memoria
Released 27/03/2009 by FAVORITE
S:58 C:36 G:14 M:8 P:0 H:2.60
235pts
6th place
Maji de watashi ni koi shinasai!
Released 28/08/2009 by Minatosoft
S:10 C:105 G:1 M:1 P:0 H:3.18
193pts
7th place
Dies irae -Acta est Fabula-
Released 25/12/2009 by Light
S:42 C:20 G:8 M:2 P:0 H:1.84
153pts
8th place
Shirokuma Bellstars
Released 11/12/2009 by Pulltop
S:18 C:58 G:4 M:0 P:0 H:3.45
147pts
9th place
Himegari dungeon meister
Released 24/04/2009 by Eushully
S:0 C:2 G:1 M:0 P:69 H:3.62
118pts
10th place
Sakura sakura
Released 26/06/2009 by Haikuosoft
S:12 C:52 G:7 M:3 P:1 H:2.97
117 pts
11) Coμ ~Kuroi Ryuu to Yasashii Oukoku~ – Akatsuki Works
12) Mashiroiro Symphony – Palette
13) Tenshinranman -LUCKY or UNLUCKY!?- – Yuzu soft
14) Natsuyumenagisa – Saga Planets
15) Kikouyokusenki Tenkuu no Yumina – ETERNAL
16) Suzunone7! – Clochette
17) Alice 2010 – Alicesoft
18) Shinigami no kiss wa wakare no aji – ALcot Citrus
19) Natsu no ame – Cube
20) Hikari no Valusia – Liar soft
21) Kyonyuu Fantasy – Waffle
22) W.L.O. Sekai Renai Kikou – Akabeesoft2
23) Bishoujo – Tanuki soft
24) Yoake mae yori ruri iro na -Moonlight Cradle- – August
25) Trample on “Schatten!!” – TailWind (closed)
Via: 2009年ベストエロゲー投票雑談スレッド
Ore tachi ni tsubasa wa nai is my personal top for best scenario for 2009. Then again I haven’t played Muramasa, Hoshizora, or Dies Irae.
