
Comic Gear is a new magazine being directed by Hiroyuki (author of Doujin Work) which runs on the new concept where all the mangaka on the magazine would get together and work in the same studio and work together on each other’s manga.
The benefits of this is that each mangaka can share their skills and knowledge with the others, and have their work looked through by all that are present and get their opinion.
And to this new magazine concept, Takato Rui (author of Cynthia the mission and MikarunX) has expressed his disapproval on his blog:
I’m sorry. But I want to directly name Comic Gear and state that I do not agree with what they’re doing. The concept itself makes me feel sick. I wonder how the person who started the project even thought of something like this in the first place. I wonder if he wants to become the leader of some friendly club. I wonder if all the young mangaka following his lead are mentally sane.
This is probably something that is already commonly said, but manga is not doujinshi. Being distressed alone, hiding from people and building up your own skills, and finally packing everything you’ve got and releasing it, that’s what you’d call your own world isn’t it.
“If we are to talk about what martial arts fighters are truly thinking, it’ll be that they’re all thinking that they’re number 1″. This is what Itagaki Keisuke wrote using the character Kuga Jyuumei.
Even if you’re still inexperienced, at least believe that you’re number 1. Show that you’re ready, be intoxicated by the loneliness, and build your own castle. By having everybody get together and draw manga that is like making a house out of candy, you won’t reincarnate into a beautiful 2D girl in your next life even if you temporarily become moderately rich for now.
They had stated that one of the merits of the magazine’s concept is that if one of them draws something boring he could be told immediately on the spot by all other mangaka. So I’m joining in from outside by saying this about their concept. I’ve never seen anything this bad in a long time.
Also it’s not very well known but Takato Rui uploads really long tracks of himself singing stuff like sentai and JAM project songs on nico.